top of page
Pickup, ASAP (in 15 minutes)
MARY COYLE ICE CREAM
CLASSIC AND CUSTOM FLAVORS
Scoops available in cup, cone, or waffle cone. Whipped cream, cherry, ground peanuts, and sprinkles available upon request.
Rich, classic flavor served Mary Coyle-style. Enjoy on its own, or add custom toppings for your own unique creation.3.30 USD
Darker and richer than traditional chocolate ice creams, our blend is made with a double-chocolate base and heavy cream.3.29 USD
Chunks of frozen strawberries mixed into a creamy traditional strawberry ice cream.3.29 USD
If you are a licorice fan, you'll love this blend. We mix chunks of Red Vines black licorice pieces and natural anise extract to make a delicious treat for the black licorice lover or occasional Scandinavian visitor.
Warning: This makes teeth green temporarily, and you WILL be smiling.3.29 USD
Smooth and creamy with a slightly sour twist at the end.
3.29 USD
Bordeaux cherries soaked in wine and sugar add an irresistible sweetness to our already rich cherry base.3.29 USD
Crushed Mount Hope pecans from the Sedona area paired with rich pecan cream.3.29 USD
Made with real coconut shavings and natural coconut extract.3.29 USD
For the true coffee lover. We blend with cold brew coffee for a concoction that is uniquely sharp and caffeinated. 3.29 USD
Chocolate chip ice cream generously endowed with satisfyingly chewy chunks of cookie dough. 3.29 USD
Real Oreo cookies crumbled into Mary Coyle house vanilla in our take on this classic.3.29 USD
Colorful like a state fair, with a festive mixture of blue raspberry and bubble gum cotton candy flavorings.3.29 USD
We use the natural earthiness of Mount Hope walnuts from the Sedona region of Arizona to enhance the subtle maple syrup flavor. Can it get any more local? 3.29 USD
Our version of mint chocolate chip features a very light mint flavor complemented by whole chocolate chips. Delicious but not overpowering.3.29 USD
Our second-best seller. We mix our own peanut butter sauce recipe into our double-chocolate ice cream as it's poured, resulting in a nice ribbon of frozen peanut butter. So good, you might want to eat it on its own!3.29 USD
Candy cane swirls of pink and white, punctuated with actual candy cane pieces and local Cerreta's peppermint candy.3.29 USD
Made with real pistachios and natural pistachio extract--no fake products or substitute nuts.3.29 USD
We take our rich double-chocolate base and blend in soft marshmallows and crunchy diced almonds.3.29 USD
Juicy rum-soaked raisins are mixed into our vanilla base to produce our rendition of this classic flavor.3.29 USD
Our best-selling flavor, this ice cream swirls caramel and salted roasted cashew pieces into an already rich Mary Coyle vanilla base.
3.29 USD
ICE CREAM ALTERNATIVES
Our sherbets are made with less dairy and more sugar, resulting in light flavors but an added boost of sweetness.
Miss a certain orange sherbet you used to get at a certain parlor in Old Town Scottsdale? Ours rocks.3.29 USD
Sweet and tangy, this refreshing favorite belongs on the beach in Hawai'i--but you can enjoy it right here in Phoenix.3.29 USD
Intense flavor for the raspberry fan. Enjoy on its own or add our other flavors to a bowl for a real fruit-focused treat.3.29 USD
Can't pick a flavor? Choose all of them. Orange, raspberry, and pineapple make a delicious blend. Put a little bit of each in your life. Available in all sizes!3.29 USD
SHOWBOATS
*Pippen sizes will use only one ice cream flavor.
Rich Mary Coyle vanilla ice cream, hot fudge sauce, Spanish peanuts. "It leaks hot fudge."4.99 USD
Vanilla and salted caramel cashew ice cream with extra caramel and cashews. "Cashews? God bless you!"4.99 USD
Cookies and cream ice cream, marshmallow, chocolate syrup, and Oreos. "It's a monster!"4.99 USD
Coffee ice cream, hot fudge, almonds. "Good till the last drop."4.99 USD
Burgundy cherry ice cream, marshmallow, coconut shavings, pureed cherries. "Bring your shovel!"4.99 USD
Mint chocolate chip and chocolate chip ice creams, marshmallow, chocolate chips. "Over the Hill."4.99 USD
Butter pecan ice cream, hot caramel, hot fudge, pecans.4.99 USD
BANANA BOWLS AND SPLITS
*One-scoop sizes will use only one ice cream flavor.
Vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry ice creams, marshmallow and pineapple toppings, with pureed cherries.4.99 USD
Your favorite Mary Coyle vanilla ice cream with rich hot fudge topping. A classic.4.99 USD
Vanilla ice cream, hot caramel. 'Nuff said.4.99 USD
Vanilla ice cream, strawberries.4.99 USD
Vanilla, Burgundy cherry and maple walnut ice creams, pineapple, coconut, walnuts.4.99 USD
Vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry ice creams, pineapple, hot fudge, and strawberry toppings. And, of course, a split banana!6.99 USD
Choose up to three ice cream flavors and up to three toppings. Add additional toppings for $0.99 each.7.99 USD
SHAKES, FLOATS, AND OTHER DESSERT DRINKS
Any flavor of ice cream, or vanilla with one flavor topping. So rich and creamy, darn right it's better than yours.5.49 USD
A milkshake with malted milk powder for increased sweetness and thickness. 5.49 USD
You know what a float is. But as a reminder any flavor of soda, and any flavor of ice cream in a chilled glass. Relive the memory of your tenth birthday!5.49 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
bottom of page